Pioneer Woman’s recipe for potato soup is called Perfect Potato Soup. I’m sure she’s right about that. It’s perfect. Just look at her photos. I’m not sure mine turned out perfectly.
Granted, I think my definition of a medium potato is smaller than her definition. Also, in lieu of the 6th potato, I used a sweet potato.
So there ya have it. If you don’t follow the recipe, you can’t expect it to turn out like the original did. Sometimes that’s a good thing. Other times, not as much. It’ll be edible. Just not perfect.